• Home
    • Comic Reviews
    • Comic Bastards Podcast
    • CBMFP
    • News
    • Press Releases
    • Interviews & Exclusives
    • Manga Reviews
    • Anime Reviews
    • Super S - Anime Podcast
  • Super S - Anime Podcast
  • Search
Menu

Comic Bastards

  • Home
  • Comics
    • Comic Reviews
    • Comic Bastards Podcast
    • CBMFP
    • News
    • Press Releases
    • Interviews & Exclusives
  • Manga
    • Manga Reviews
  • Anime
    • Anime Reviews
    • Super S - Anime Podcast
  • Super S - Anime Podcast
  • Search
JLA-#17-Banner.png

Review: Justice League of America #17

October 25, 2017

By Jonathan Edwards

“Panic in the Microverse” is finally over and thank god. I addition to the regular problems with this book, this particular arc has really dragged. And, it’s no mystery why. Injecting two full issue-length flashbacks right in the middle of your story, and before the cliffhanger you previously ended on, does no favors for pacing. That’s especially true when neither of said flashbacks provide any useful or necessary information and plot progression. But, that’s the past. How is Justice League of America #17 here in the present? Well, to be honest, it’s not bad. There are still a few hiccups along the way, but the core premise of how to stop the Microverse from being destroyed is sound, and we actually get a good chunk of time dedicated to developing Ryan’s character. Not counting any of the JLA Rebirth one-shots, this might be the best issue of this series to date.

However, a couple things in this issue could’ve worked a bit better if those flashbacks hadn’t tried to set them up first. For example, the foundations of Aron Aut’s (I’m not calling him ‘Null,’ because that’s a stupid name) logic for why it makes sense to exacerbate the effects of the Ignition Point established last time completely fall apart here. Supposedly, it was because his scans ‘proved’ there was no way to fix it, and a quick destruction was the merciful option. Yet, when Ryan suggests a theory that neither he nor Palmer has considered, Aut doesn’t even take a second to consider it. Instead, he just screams about how “thousands of deaths across the Immensity, more, would be for nothing!” Of course, that makes no goddamn sense. Up until now, Aut has been concerned with preventing the suffering of millions at the hands of the Quantum Storms caused by the Ignition Point. Again, “everyone is going to die anyway, so a quick and painless death is better.” But now, it’s suddenly about the lives already lost ‘meaning something?’ Really, it wouldn’t have made sense even without his flashback, but what’s the point in dedicating an issue to developing a character’s backstory if it’s not going to come at all into play in the climax? It wouldn’t even be hard to do. Have Ryan try and sacrifice himself like he does, and then Aut, after realizing Ryan is right, stops him, switches belts, Ryan tries to stop him, he says something about always liking the concept of ‘zero,’ and then, Aut sacrifices himself instead. Boom. Ryan would maintain the development he’s supposed to get, and Aut would be more than a one-note villain. Hell, I actually thought that was the direction the story was going up until it became obvious it wasn’t.

JLA-#17.png

The other thing I wish we really hadn’t seen earlier was the fact that Palmer and Preon are romantically involved. I know it’s small, but it would’ve been so much punchier to see them reunite and then suddenly kiss. Sure, it would probably require some exposition afterward, but it would’ve been fine in context and allow for a moment when the JLA, the reader, or both can realize how much of a mistake it really was to side with Aut over Preon. Speaking of small things, I still fail to understand how Palmer can question why Ryan would bring Aut to the Ignition Point. He does it again here, even though Ryan had literally no way of knowing that Aut was a bad guy. Furthermore, why does he wholly blame Ryan when most of the JLA is also there? For all Palmer knows, it was a group decision (which it kind of was), and Ryan didn’t have control one way or the other.

As for the art, it’s all pretty good. Nothing to complain about, at least in terms of the interior art. I don’t usually talk about covers, but this one in particular really bothers me. And okay, technically it’s not the art itself. It’s the concept: “Ray vs. Ryan! Who will be The Atom?” Yes, I get that it’s supposed to be a spin of what actually happens by the end of the issue, but it’s a pretty substantial stretch. And yes, I know that similarly deceptive covers have been used many, many times by other books, but that’s not a valid reason to do it again. Covers like this risk misleading a reader by promising a story different from what’s actually in the issue. They could very easily pick it up based on that, and I personally don’t think that’s the right way to sell books.

Even though Justice League of America #17 ended up being mostly okay, I still wouldn’t really recommend it. It’s not an especially great issue, and it does nothing to counteract the mediocrity of the rest of this arc and, really, the series as a whole. Plus, the teaser for the next one doesn’t make it seem like it’s going to be all that good either. Maybe it’s the mention of the Might Beyond the Mirror and her involvement with it, or maybe it’s that “showing the hypocrisy of Justice” isn’t an interesting idea. I don’t know, but I’m not looking forward to it.

Score: 3/5

Justice League of America #17
DC Comics

In Comic Reviews Tags Jonathan Edwards, Justice League of America, JLA, Steve Orlando, DC Comics
← Review: Void Trip #1Review: Justice League of America #17 →

FEATURED POSTS

Featured
Review: Transdimensional #1
Mar 14, 2018
Review: Transdimensional #1
Mar 14, 2018
Mar 14, 2018
Review: Dragon Ball Super E.127
Feb 23, 2018
Review: Dragon Ball Super E.127
Feb 23, 2018
Feb 23, 2018
Comic Bastards Podcast - 018
Nov 1, 2017
Comic Bastards Podcast - 018
Nov 1, 2017
Nov 1, 2017
Super S - Anime Podcast E.037
Oct 29, 2017
Super S - Anime Podcast E.037
Oct 29, 2017
Oct 29, 2017
Super S - Anime Podcast E.036
Oct 14, 2017
Super S - Anime Podcast E.036
Oct 14, 2017
Oct 14, 2017

  • January 2019 2
  • August 2018 13
  • July 2018 188
  • June 2018 159
  • May 2018 204
  • April 2018 156
  • March 2018 178
  • February 2018 170
  • January 2018 176
  • December 2017 112
  • November 2017 143
  • October 2017 152
  • September 2017 210
  • August 2017 179
  • July 2017 199
  • June 2017 150
  • May 2017 129
  • April 2017 184
  • March 2017 180
  • February 2017 176
  • January 2017 195
  • December 2016 164
  • November 2016 135
  • October 2016 163
  • September 2016 219
  • August 2016 248
  • July 2016 267
  • June 2016 242
  • May 2016 160
  • April 2016 199
  • March 2016 163
  • February 2016 145
  • January 2016 175
  • December 2015 105
  • November 2015 166
  • October 2015 130
  • September 2015 147
  • August 2015 135
  • July 2015 183
  • June 2015 190
  • May 2015 140
  • April 2015 275
  • March 2015 198
  • February 2015 430
  • January 2015 198
  • December 2014 144
  • November 2014 187
  • October 2014 239
  • September 2014 193
  • August 2014 289
  • July 2014 334
  • June 2014 308
  • May 2014 244
  • April 2014 253
  • March 2014 268
  • February 2014 232
  • January 2014 254
  • December 2013 302
  • November 2013 276
  • October 2013 349
  • September 2013 262
  • August 2013 325
  • July 2013 349
  • June 2013 303
  • May 2013 373
  • April 2013 416
  • March 2013 124
  • February 2013 16
  • January 2013 26
  • December 2012 24
  • November 2012 17
  • October 2012 18
  • September 2012 22
  • August 2012 13
  • July 2012 20
  • June 2012 12
  • May 2012 23
  • April 2012 20
  • March 2012 9
  • February 2012 20
  • January 2012 96
  • December 2011 93
  • November 2011 73
  • October 2011 52
  • September 2011 54
  • August 2011 37
  • July 2011 1

Listen To Super S p4.png
google-play-badge.png
Available on iTunes.png

COMING SOON!

Copyright Comic Bastards 2011-2017